What to know about the Trump-era rollback of bank rules and Silicon Valley Bank's demise (2024)

The collapse of Silicon Valley Bank is putting deregulatory reforms implemented under former President Donald Trump back in the spotlight.

The abrupt implosion of the country's 16th-largest bank last week resulted in swift finger-pointing in Washington.

President Joe Biden and many progressive Democrats have blamed, in part, a 2018 law that rolled back some of the Dodd-Frank Act -- a series of federal regulations passed in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis. Republicans, on the other hand, are decrying so-called "woke" practices at the bank as well as government spending and inflation as the culprits.

MORE: Why are some Republicans blaming bank failures on 'woke' policies?
What to know about the Trump-era rollback of bank rules and Silicon Valley Bank's demise (1)

Though there's more to learn about the bank's downfall, several experts told ABC News it was a failure of regulation and supervision.

"The Federal Reserve completely missed major classic red flags at Silicon Valley Bank," said Aaron Klein, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution.

Here's what you need to know as the political fallout continues.

What is the Dodd-Frank Act?

In response to the worst recession since the Great Depression, Congress passed a sprawling law in 2010 overhauling federal financial regulation.

One of its major provisions was designating any bank with more than $50 billion in assets a "systemically important" financial institution -- or "too big to fail" -- and thus subject to enhanced prudential standards, such as "stress tests" and certain capital planning and liquidity requirements.

"Dodd-Frank massively empowered the Federal Reserve to more forcefully regulate banks, including those where it wasn't the direct bank regulator," Klein said.

What did Trump do?

The Dodd-Frank Act was met with animosity from the industry, which argued the regulations were burdensome and only necessary for the largest banks. Silicon Valley Bank's CEO Gregory Becker was among those calling for lighter regulations.

After years of political pressure, Congress passed a law that rolled back some of those rules for smaller and mid-tier banks.

Among the biggest changes was raising the asset threshold for "systemically important" institutions from $50 billion to $250 billion. Under the law, the Federal Reserve still had the right to apply the Dodd-Frank regulations to banks with at least $100 billion in assets if they chose to do so.

Trump signed it into law in May 2018, calling it "big deal for our country." The push to alter Dodd-Frank split the Democratic Party, and ultimately more than a dozen Senate Democrats joined Republicans to support the deregulations.

"It reduced stress testing, it reduced collateral calculations, it reduced the supervisory stress test and it enabled them not to publicly conduct or report their own company-run stress tests," Dennis Kelleher, the president & CEO of the nonprofit Better Markets, said of the 2018 law. "It blew a hole in several of the key financial stability protection rules."

Debate rages over 2018 law amid SVB's collapse

Critics, including Democratic Sen. Elizabeth Warren and independent Sen. Bernie Sanders, have said the law's softening of regulations contributed to Silicon Valley Bank's demise.

Former Democratic Rep. Barney Frank, co-author of the Dodd-Frank Act and a board member of the recently shutdown Signature Bank, told Bloomberg he didn't think the 2018 changes had an impact. Trump, too, defended it, claiming banks were getting "eaten alive" by regulations.

And some Democrats who backed the law are defending it. Sen. Mark Warner told "This Week" on Sunday he thought it "put in place an appropriate level of regulation on mid-sized banks." Sen. Tim Kaine said regional and community banks "really needed" the relief at the time, and that "solutions should wait until there's an analysis of causes."

Amid the debate, experts told ABC News stress tests and other financial-safety requirements may have caught problems at the institution earlier but there were warning signs Federal Reserve supervisors should've seen regardless.

"This was a failure of supervision ... the red flags that were going on at SVB, you didn't need enhanced prudential standards to catch that," Klein said.

MORE: Is this a banking crisis? What to know about the Silicon Valley Bank collapse

Those concerns included the bank's explosive asset growth, its reliance on uninsured deposits and the impact of high interest rates on its long-term bonds.

"Those deregulatory reforms may well have contributed to laxer rather than stricter oversight," Lawrence Baxter, a law professor at Duke University and former executive at Wachovia, said of the 2018 law. "Having said that, I don't think the regulators are entirely off the hook because they still have power to take action when they observe rapid deterioration. And we'll have to find out why they didn't."

What's next?

Biden on Monday specifically cited the Trump-era rollbacks as he addressed the banking system, vowing to work for more regulation.

"I'm going to ask Congress and the banking regulators to strengthen the rules for banks to make it less likely that this kind of bank failure will happen again and to protect American jobs and small businesses," the president said.

Warren and Rep. Katie Porter, D-Calif., have already unveiled legislation to repeal the 2018 rollbacks.

Republicans, so far, have expressed no interest in revisiting the law. Rep. Patrick McHenry, a North Carolina Republican who chairs the House Financial Services Committee, said he has "confidence in our financial regulators and the protections already in place to ensure the safety and soundness of our financial system." Sen. Mike Crapo, an Idaho Republican on the Senate Banking Committee, told Fox News that "nothing in the Dodd-Frank reforms we put together did anything with regard to this crisis."

Meanwhile, the Justice Department and Securities and Exchange Commission are investigating the Silicon Valley Bank's collapse, two people familiar with the situation confirmed to ABC News. The Federal Reserve Board is also reviewing the supervision and regulation of the bank, which is set to be released by May 1.

What to know about the Trump-era rollback of bank rules and Silicon Valley Bank's demise (2024)

FAQs

How did the government respond to the Silicon Valley bank collapse? ›

Silicon Valley Bank (SVB)—the 16th largest bank in the United States—was shut down by federal regulators on March 10, 2023. In the aftermath of the collapse, federal regulators promised to make all depositors whole, even for those funds that weren't protected by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC).

When did banking deregulation start? ›

The 1980s have been characterized as the decade of deregulation in the financial industry. Two major national legislative bills and numerous state proposals have been approved permitting banking activities that were previously disallowed .

What caused the banking crisis of 1933? ›

By early 1933, the Depression had been ravaging the American economy and its banks for nearly four years. Mistrust in financial institutions grew, prompting a rising flood of Americans to withdraw their money from the system rather than risk leaving it in banks.

What is the history of bank runs? ›

A brief history of bank runs

Before the Great Depression, bank runs—and more widespread financial panics—were fairly common. They were typically set off by a rapid change in the business cycle from boom and overconfidence to a return to reality and, ultimately, to fears of a crash.

What was the main reason for the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank? ›

SVB didn't have the cash on hand to liquidate these deposits because they were tied up in long-term investments. They started selling their bonds at a significant loss, which caused distress to customers and investors. Within 48 hours after disclosing the sale of assets, the bank collapsed.

What banks are collapsing in 2024? ›

2024 Summary by Month
Bank NamePress ReleaseClosing Date
April Back to Top
Republic First Bank dba Republic Bank, Philadelphia, PAPR-030-2024April 26, 2024

Top Articles
Warren Buffett Stocks: What is Berkshire Hathaway Holding, Buying and Selling? - NerdWallet
Big Wins For BTS & Co. As Big Hit Entertainment Goes Public & Prices Fluctuate
Tears Of The Fallen Moon Bdo
Does Shell Gas Station Sell Pregnancy Tests
Victoria Tortilla & Tamales Factory Menu
Google Sites 1V1.Lol
Jsmainnn
Elgin Il Building Department
Xenia Canary Dragon Age Origins
Craiglist Tulsa Ok
Pierced Universe Coupon
Terraria Melee Build Progression Guide & Best Class Loadouts
Cooktopcove Com
5 Best Brokerage Accounts for High Interest Rates on Cash Sweep - NerdWallet
Flappy Bird Cool Math Games
Mo Money Login
Browse | Obituaries | Enid News and Eagle
Unit 5 Lesson 6 Coding Activity
Binny Arcot
Dovob222
Are Crazyjamjam Leaks Real or Fake?
50 Shades Of Grey Movie 123Movies
Volstate Portal
E23.Ultipro
Elanco Rebates.com 2022
Cn/As Archives
Boys golf: Back-nine surge clinches Ottumwa Invite title for DC-G
Clarkson Eyecare hiring Optometrist - Fredericksburg, VA in Fredericksburg, VA | LinkedIn
Ipayonline Azsdu Net
Audarite
Pair sentenced for May 2023 murder of Roger Driesel
Monkey Werx Sitrep 2022
Rubios Listens Com
Mike Temara
The Bold And The Beautiful Soap Hub
Tackytwinzzbkup
Peoplesgamezgiftexchange House Of Fun Coins
Witchwood Icon
Enterprise Car Sales Jacksonville Used Cars
Bullmastiff vs English Mastiff: How Are They Different?
Nahant Magic Seaweed
Lake Erie Noaa Near Shore
Doublelist Aiken Sc
Briggs And Stratton 125Cc Lawn Mower
Craigslist Ct Bridgeport
Press-Citizen Obituaries
Craigs List Outdoor Furniture
Watch Stephen Miller Have A Full Meltdown When Asked To Back Up Crime Claim With Facts
Craiglist Horses For Sale
Evangeline Shrine Club Banquet Hall Photos
Six Broadway Wiki
Baja Boats For Sale On Craigslist
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Roderick King

Last Updated:

Views: 6484

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Roderick King

Birthday: 1997-10-09

Address: 3782 Madge Knoll, East Dudley, MA 63913

Phone: +2521695290067

Job: Customer Sales Coordinator

Hobby: Gunsmithing, Embroidery, Parkour, Kitesurfing, Rock climbing, Sand art, Beekeeping

Introduction: My name is Roderick King, I am a cute, splendid, excited, perfect, gentle, funny, vivacious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.