Our investment and economic outlook, May 2023 (2024)

In mid-March, the last time the Fed issued rate projections, policymakers foresaw no rate cuts by year-end. Futures pricing suggested a starkly different view in the markets—a bit more than 70 basis points (0.70 percentage points) of rate cuts by year-end. By mid-May, futures prices had changed modestly, implying about 60 basis points of rate cuts.

Yet “the Fed’s views and those of the market may not be as far off as they appear,” said Rhea Thomas, a Vanguard economist.

The Federal Reserve Bank of New York conducts surveys of both primary dealers—firms authorized to trade government securities directly with the Fed—and market participants. Those surveys should largely reflect the views of key market actors. And in mid-March they were much more closely aligned with the Fed’s own projections, looking for the rate target to end the year close to its peak. (Vanguard participates in the New York Fed survey of market participants.)

Why the difference between survey-based market expectations and those based on futures prices? One key reason is that survey-based expectations reflect the modal, or most likely, expected outcome. In contrast, futures-based pricing incorporates the average expectation across the distribution of all probabilities—including outliers that may distort the average—along with a risk premium. As a result, survey-based expectations may provide a clearer picture of where markets ultimately expect the federal funds rate target to land.

Vanguard’s own view is that the Fed won’t cut its key rate target before 2024 because of its need to keep policy sufficiently restrictive to bring inflation back toward its 2% target.

The views below are those of the global economics and markets team of Vanguard Investment Strategy Group as of May 17, 2023.

With inflation still too high and the labor market still tight, we expect Federal Reserve policymakers to raise their target for short-term interest rates once more next month. In a change to our forecast, we expect that hike to be the last in a series that so far spans 10 meetings and 5 percentage points. We now see the Fed’s terminal rate in a range of 5.25%–5.5%, just a quarter of a percentage point higher than the current rate target. We also have raised our year-end inflation forecast and modified our labor market forecast.

• “The Fed’s reaction function appears to have shifted,” said Josh Hirt, a Vanguard senior economist. “The economic data warrant further rate hikes in our view, but it’s now likely that even one more [rate hike] is going to be a close call.”
• Economic indicators that would typically drive Fed monetary policy decisions have generally moved sideways of late, Hirt said. But we perceive a shift by the Fed toward greater risk management, owing to recent banking system stresses and federal debt ceiling concerns.
• We’ve increased our forecast for year-end 2023 core inflation, which excludes volatile food and energy prices, from 3% to 3.3%.
• The wait for a downturn in the U.S. labor market goes on. We believe the Fed will want to see the ratio of job vacancies to the number of unemployed fall further. We anticipate an unemployment rate of around 4.5% at year-end 2023, the lower end of our previous expectation of 4.5%–5%.
• We believe the pace of services spending (2.3% on an annual basis in the first quarter) will need to slow to reduce the pace of price growth.
• Another quarter of broad-based decline in business investment, down 12.5% on an annual basis in the first quarter, suggests softening in the broader economy.

A 4.5% first-quarter increase in GDP compared with a year earlier, powered by consumers tapping their savings after COVID-19-related lockdowns in 2022, may well represent peak 2023 economic activity in China.

Although strong tourism and hospitality data from the May Labor Day holidays show pent-up demand carrying into the second quarter, four recent developments cast doubt on the sustainability of the recovery:

• Service-sector activity has outpaced the production of goods;
• Public investment has outpaced private investment;
• Housing completions have increased but housing starts have declined; and
• While the overall unemployment rate has fallen, youth unemployment has climbed.

“As the reopening surge fades and external demand deteriorates, further growth recovery in China hinges on continued labor market and income recovery, improving private confidence, and continued policy support,” said Grant Feng, a Vanguard economist. We foresee full-year GDP growth in a range of 6%–6.5%, higher than the government’s official 2023 growth target of “around 5%” but decelerating toward trend in coming quarters.

Unlike that of the Federal Reserve a day earlier, the European Central Bank’s (ECB’s) monetary policy stance, as articulated on May 4, was unequivocal: Interest rates are not sufficiently restrictive to tame inflation. The ECB raised its deposit facility rate by 25 basis points to 3.25%. Although the seventh consecutive hike marked a slowing in the rate of increases after three successive 50-point hikes, President Christine Lagarde made clear in her post-announcement news conference that the rate-hiking cycle isn’t over.

• Based on our economic view of persistent inflationary pressures, a still-tight labor market, and the limited impact of banking stresses on credit conditions thus far, we expect the ECB to raise the deposit facility to a range of 3.75%–4% over the next several months. Markets have moved closer to our terminal rate outlook in the last month, as well as to our view that rates won’t be cut in 2023.
  
• We continue to expect core inflation to peak in a range of 5.5%–6% in the next few months before fading in the second half of the year as the effects of higher interest rates work their way through the economy. We foresee core inflation averaging 4.5% in 2023 and ending the year around 3.3%—still solidly above the ECB’s 2% target.
• We continue to expect 0.5% euro area growth for all of 2023, with a mild recession later in the year. However, “in both the euro area and the United Kingdom, risks have risen for a delayed landing, with recession not occurring until 2024 and higher central bank interest rates for longer required to tame inflation,” said Roxane Spitznagel, a Vanguard economist.

Inflation, the labor market, and overall economic activity have been stronger than expected, leading us to increase our forecasts for GDP growth, inflation, and the Bank of England (BOE) terminal rate.

“We continue to anticipate a recession later this year, though shallower than we had previously thought,” said Roxane Spitznagel, a Vanguard economist. “Recent developments increase the risk, however, of a ‘later landing’—a deeper recession, delayed into 2024, with higher-than-anticipated interest rates required to counter stickier inflation.”

• We’ve revised our forecast for 2023 GDP to no growth from a previous forecast for a contraction of around 1%. We’ve ratcheted down our 2024 growth forecast from 0.6% to 0.2%, reflecting the impact of a likely higher BOE terminal rate.
• Based on the accrued inflation data and our revised growth forecast, we’ve increased our year-end 2023 forecast for headline inflation from 3.4% to 3.7% and for core inflation from 2.8% to 3.6%.
• With upgrades to both our growth and inflation forecasts, we’ve raised our monetary policy forecast as well. We now expect the BOE to raise the bank rate to a range of 4.75%–5% (up from 4.5%), likely in the third quarter, and keep it there at least until 2024.

Our growth upgrade for China and resilient activity globally have led us to increase our forecast for 2023 emerging markets GDP growth from 3.25% to 3.9%. “Emerging market manufacturing indexes are holding up well, and so are softer indicators such as business and consumer sentiment,” said Vytas Maciulis, a Vanguard economist. “Even emerging Europe, where the inflation challenges are greatest, is contributing to the improved sentiment.”

We believe:

• Emerging Asia will lead the way in 2023, growing about 5%. Latin America is likely to grow about 1.5%, and central Europe, the Middle East, and Africa are likely to grow about 1%. As in many developed markets, the chances are increasing that further economic slowdowns could be delayed until 2024.
• Inflation has largely peaked in emerging markets.
• Emerging markets central banks have largely reached the peaks of their rate-hiking cycles and will likely cut rates before developed market central banks.
• With its key rate at its highest level since at least 2005 and with inflation declining slowly, the Bank of Mexico has reached its terminal rate, though we don’t expect it to cut rates before 2024.

The Bank of Canada wrestled at its April 12 policy meeting with a choice of raising its interest rate target or keeping it steady for a second consecutive month, meeting minutes show. In the end, the Governing Council voted to keep its rate target at 4.5% to give itself “the opportunity to accumulate more evidence that a higher policy rate is in fact required.”

Among the rationales for raising the rate target was the idea that—although the pace of inflation has edged down—getting from 3% inflation to the bank’s 2% target was likely to be the hardest increment. The Governing Council considered that a further rate hike might be deemed necessary.

“High core and services inflation can eventually show up in higher wages,” said Asawari Sathe, a Vanguard senior economist. “The Bank of Canada is worried about such sticky inflation. With the labor market as strong as it is, we believe monetary policy may have to tighten further.”

We continue to foresee 2023 GDP growth of about 1%, with risks to the downside, and a recession late in the year.

The pause in the Reserve Bank of Australia’s (RBA’s) rate-hiking cycle was short-lived. Having interrupted a string of 10 consecutive hikes at its April meeting to “assess the state of the economy and the outlook,” the RBA raised its cash rate by 25 basis points this month. The rate, now 3.85%, is at an 11-year high. In its statement, the bank said that although inflation had passed its peak, it is “still too high and it will be some time yet before it is back in the target range.”

• We've increased our outlook for the RBA’s terminal rate, from 3.6% to 4.1%, based on the bank’s comments and our view that the unemployment rate will remain lower for longer, which could keep upward pressure on wages and services inflation. Our view is more hawkish than that of financial markets, which assign only about a 20% chance of a further rate hike.
• “Our baseline view for the RBA is one more rate hike, with risks skewed toward even further tightening if services inflation remains sticky, and no rate cuts this year,” said Alexis Gray, a Vanguard senior economist.
• We expect headline inflation to fall to around 4.25% on a year-over-year basis by the end of 2023, as higher interest rates dampen demand, and to fall to the RBA’s target band of 2%–3% in late 2024 or 2025.
• We expect the unemployment rate, which was unchanged at 3.5% in March, to rise gradually this year as financial conditions tighten.
• We continue to expect GDP growth of 1%–1.5% for all of 2023, and we assign a 50% probability of recession over the next 12 months.

• In America and Europe, higher rates for longer (article, issued May 2023)
• Personalized inflation hedging: A closer look at your true consumer price index (research paper, PDF, issued February 2023)
• U.S. shelter costs, a source of inflation pressure, will ease (article, issued November 2022)